Our analysis of US Department of Transportation data reveals RASM for full-service airlines fell 50 percent year-over-year in 2020's second quarter, probably the darkest period for US carriers. There are fundame. In North America, the airline industry is expected to deliver an estimated profit of $8.8 billion in 2022, thanks to efficiency gains and . In, IATA. EBITDA as percentage of revenues (seasonally adjusted) by region: 2005 to 2011F Please create an employee account to be able to mark statistics as favorites. Are you interested in testing our business solutions? Calculation: Gross profit margin = Gross profit / Revenue. This more stable period came after an intense squeeze on profit margins during the earlier part of 2018 as unit costs Carsten Spohr, CEO of Deutsche Lufthansa AG, said: "Lufthansa is back. Seat capacity on services touching Europe was 1.08 billion. Annual car sales worldwide 2010-2022, with a forecast for 2023, Number of cars sold in the U.S. 1951-2021, Battery electric vehicles in use worldwide 2016-2021, Annual gas prices in the United States 1990-2021, Automotive industry worldwide - statistics & facts, Motorcycle industry in the United States - statistics & facts, Profit from additional features with an Employee Account. The airline industry has seen sustained profitability since 2010, with global profits reaching a peak of $38 billion in 2017, according to the International Air Transport Association. As well as stiff competition from their rivals, airlines face the problem that there is little competition in the industries that supply them. But though the industry has done much to connect the world, it has done little to line the pockets of the airlines themselves. EBIT margin of commercial airlines worldwide from 2010 to 2022, by region [Graph]. Lets take two examples of gross profit margin in a (real) companys financial statements, through their publicly filed annual report (or 10-k). To put it in context: Delta Air Lines, once again the most profitable airline group in the world in 2019 with a net profit of $4.8 billion, this year posted a net loss of $5.7 billion in the . Airline capacity rose at its quickest rate over the second half of the decade as fuel prices relented. The airline industry is infamous for difficulties in maintaining profit margins amid a number of internal and external factors that consistently threaten to throw them off balance. Get full access to all features within our Business Solutions. Airlines continued to receive life support from their governments, totaling $243 billion since the beginning of the pandemic. Strategy executive in international markets with established sales, marketing and business development background<br>Extensive contributions with airlines, Credit Card companies, improving profit margins, growing market share/revenues and managing costs<br>Recognized leader by management, teams and customers, strong negotiation skills, committed and results oriented<br>Significant . Currently, you are using a shared account. among other factors. Airlines increased by a little over half their seat capacity on Europe services during the decade, making it the second largest region at 1.64 billion seats. Gross profit margin is one of the three main margins formulas in a companys income statement which measures a companys efficiency in creating profitability. Not unsurprisingly given the relatively benign economic backdrop of the decade, the last 10 years has seen global airline capacity on the rise every year. Airline margins stabilizing in difficult business environment In last week's Airlines Financial Monitor we reported on an apparent stabilization in operating margins at the industry level . Indeed only one of the 10 biggest airlines in 2009 made it into the black that year. This is significantly better than losses of $42.0 billion and $137.7 billion that were realized in 2021 and 2020 respectively. Notably growth on services touching China increased by 150% - at an annual compound growth rate of just shy of 10%. Now that we know how to calculate gross profit margin, its time to think about the implications of the metric. stream Their other benefits were discovered by accident, Millions lack citizenship around the world, putting them in a precarious position, It has one tank factory, and is increasingly reliant on refurbishing old models, Published since September 1843 to take part in a severe contest between intelligence, which presses forward, and an unworthy, timid ignorance obstructing our progress.. Management and/or analysts might have better reasoning to why this is the case rather than not, in which case the company reports Gross Margins above 50%; my point is that a good analysis of gross margin should require a judgment call especially if comparing to peers when some metrics have the possibility of not being 100% clear. 2021 Annual Results for All 25 Scheduled Passenger Airlines. Globally, operating profit margins for leading players have typically been in the midteenseven exceeding 20% for some carriers. Low-cost carriers devastated their model of feeding short-haul passengers onto more lucrative long-haul services. For one, we want to make sure we are comparing gross margins between peers. The World Airline Rankings showed the 100 biggest airline group posted collective operating profits of almost $50 billion in 2018. Despite sequential Revenue deterioration in 4 Q 2022 of. Prediction 2 :- attractive profit margins would possibly lead to the formation of new airlines:- (Assumption) 'Attractive Profit margin' is a one of the factors in the formation of an airline. In those six decades passenger kilometres (the number of flyers multiplied by the distance they travel) have gone from almost zero to more than 5 trillion a year. Grant is a principal, based in Washington DC, in the transportation practice. One attractive feature of calculating gross margins is that, according to the data, companies with high gross margins are likely to sustain those over the very long term. JavaScript chart by amCharts 3.21.13. Still, profit margins continue to grow because costs have dropped more than the revenue drop. Long-established airlines regularly yelp that the Gulf newcomers get state handouts in the form of reduced landing fees and subsidised fuel from the governments of Dubai, Qatar and Abu Dhabi, though the charges are largely unwarranted. While the pandemic has changed things drastically, United will undoubtedly be hoping to return to its glory days as soon as possible. endobj Persistently strong demand for air travel is pushing many carriers to add capacity, but the additional routes and service are making pricing more competitive and putting pressure on yields. Among the destinations in the codeshare are Ahmedabad, Bengaluru, Chandigarh, Goa, Hyderabad, Jodhpur, Srinagar, Thiruvananthapuram, Udaipur and Varanasi. Theres no doubt that the rising demand for air travel is encouraging airlines to focus on the need for new capacity and the potential to expand revenue and market share even if such moves mean potentially sacrificing margins and reducing yield. Smaller companies will likely. Oliver Wymans Grant Alport, Andy Buchanan, and Aaron Taylor contributed to the research and insights in the 2019 Airline Economic Analysis and in this article. U.S. airline costs declined 12.6 percent year-over-year to 11.5 cents per available seat mile in. The result was inefficiency and losses. Opinions expressed by Forbes Contributors are their own. Proven success benchmarking pace-setting results in KPI. Comparing the gross margin of a thin margins retailer like Target to a capital light software company is not fair and tells us nothing about the attractiveness of an investment. "Ebit Margin of Commercial Airlines Worldwide from 2010 to 2022, by Region. This number will be a percentage, where the higher the percentage the more profitable a company is on delivering their goods or services. Cleveland, Ohio, United States. This formula can be useful for uncovering if a company has a competitive advantage, more on that later. While prices subsequently recovered, they have remained relatively stable since. ** Forecast, Global air traffic - scheduled passengers 2004-2022, Worldwide air traffic - number of fatalities 2006-2021, Global air traffic - annual growth of passenger demand 2006-2022, Fatal civil airliner accidents by country and region 1945-2022. 1 Delta Air Lines The prize for the most profitable airline in the world goes to none other than Delta Air Lines. That followed Deltas merger with Northwest Airlines at the end of the previous decade. The airline says it achieved a fourth-quarter net profit a figure of $8.5 million for the first time since 2015, although it points out Latvian carrier Air Baltic has returned to full-year operating profit, with a surplus of 32 million ($34 million), although its net result remained negative with a loss of 54 million. It is the first profit since 2019. Commercial airlines - global EBIT margin 2010-2022 Published by Statista Research Department , Feb 3, 2023 Following a dramatic increase in 2015, the EBIT margin of commercial airlines. Compare this with the high correlation in gross profitability. Margin Industry Ranking. Gulf carriers Emirates, Etihad Airways and Qatar Airways have been among the fastest expanding carriers during this period. "Net Profit of Commercial Airlines Worldwide from 2006 to 2022 (in Billion U.S. Heres a company called Booz Allen Hamilton ($BAH), they provide consulting to the government, and the income statement from their latest 10-k: We can see that Gross Profit is not explicitly expressed in this 10-k, so we must make our own calculation. Did you know which airlines were the most profitable in the world? You need a Statista Account for unlimited access. Please do not hesitate to contact me. I like using the free website bamsec.com to quickly pull up a companys financial documents. IAG is the parent company behind British Airways, Iberia, Vueling, and several other European airline companies. Profitability is a rare phenomenon for most airlines, but there are some that bring in billions every year. You can learn more about the cookies we use here, Airline Business Covid-19 recovery tracker. Chart. The aviation industry is facing a predicted shortage of 55,000 pilots predicted by the end of the decade. Obviously we want to see increasing operating margins over time. After-tax net income $2.2 billion loss in 4Q 2021 Compared to $2.7 billion profit in 3Q 2021 Compared to $7.0 billion loss in 4Q 2020 Pre-tax operating profit $894 million loss in 4Q 2021 You need at least a Starter Account to use this feature. This is due to the nature of their contracts being serviced to various U.S. government entities. Airlines returned comfortably to the black in the 2010/11 financial year which was to start an unprecedented run of profitability. The last two reasons have been the driving force behind deployments in the airline industry. Guide to Business Aviation Training and Safety 2022. Dig deeper:Jumbo jets v swallows: comparing long-distance flights with migrating birds (December 2013)Why the world's biggest airport should be dug up and moved (December 2013)Asia's airports soar while America's leave passengers reaching for their sick-bags (April 2013), They were intended to treat diabetes. The Atlanta-based megacarrier recorded a net income of $4.76 billion in 2019 with a revenue of $47 billion, a huge margin of 10%. A few surprising takeaways were that past revenue growth was generally NOT indicative of future revenue growth; future revenue growth was pretty random. Airline financial performance is expected to recover in all regions in2022. Based on current trends and pressures, the operating margin for US airlines is expected to narrow to between five and six percent in 2019 a margin that is less than 40 percent of the industrys peak of 15 percent in 2015. Schiphols operator says this is a necessary intermediate step as it FlightGlobal is the global aviation communitys primary source of news, data, insight, knowledge and expertise. Returns on capital are expected to . A cross-route analysis further suggests that annual profit margins increase with the market share of the largest airline serving the route, whereas they decrease with airfare. These higher costs were only partially offset by fuel surcharges the airlines implemented to mitigate the higher fuel costs. A paid subscription is required for full access. As well see later thats a pretty high gross margin, and it speaks to the wide profits currently available for the critical, high tech semiconductors which are such a large part of the goods economy today. Another competitor listed by Atlas Technical Consultants was Huron Consulting Group, and their income statement looked like the following: After understanding the nature of these contracts, we can understand that billable expenses and reimbursable expenses are essentially the same thing. Usually, if I were to see a company like this, I would just take Cost of Revenue and subtract that from Revenue to get Gross Profit. Airlines only make $164 for every $16,400 they spend on the typical domestic flight, according to an analysis by Oliver Wyman at the Wall Street Journal. The liberalisation of air travel in the 1980s led to competition from upstarts to the state behemoths, many of which were privatised wholly or partly. The fact that margins were in the teens from 2015 to 2017, even though on the decline, reflects the impact of lower oil prices. While profits peaked at record high levels during the middle years of the decade, they have remained relatively high even as pressures increased. The World Airline Rankings showed the 100 biggest airline group posted collective operating profits of almost $50 billion in 2018. Lead Journalist - India - Pranjal is an experienced journalist with a strong focus on Indian aviation. to incorporate the statistic into your presentation at any time. California: Do Not Sell My Personal Information, Jumbo jets v swallows: comparing long-distance flights with migrating birds, Why the world's biggest airport should be dug up and moved, Asia's airports soar while America's leave passengers reaching for their sick-bags, How the new generation of weight-loss drugs work, Why statelessness is bad for countries and people. Industry margins reached 15 percent, helped by oil prices that averaged around $50 a barrel. Air Transport Services net profit margin as of September 30, 2022 is 9.71% . Use Ask Statista Research Service. Miscellaneous Fabricated Products Industry, Industrial Machinery and Components Industry, Renewable Energy Services & Equipment Industry, Miscellaneous Financial Services Industry, Major Pharmaceutical Preparations Industry, Laboratory Analytical Instruments Industry, In Vitro & In Vivo Diagnostic Substances Industry, Print Media & Newspaper Publishing Industry, Computer Peripherals & Office Equipment Industry, Internet Services & Social Media Industry, Electronic Instruments & Controls Industry, Computer processing and cloud services Industry, Scientific & Technical Instruments Industry, Internet, Mail Order & Online Shops Industry, Pharmacy Services & Retail Drugstore Industry, More Airline Industry historic profitability ratios >>, Compare Industry's gross margin to Vicr's or S&P, Compare Industry's EBITDA margin to Vicr's or S&P, Compare Industry's pre-tax margin to Vicr's or S&P, Compare Industry's net margin to Vicr's or S&P. Profit margins increase with the market share of the largest airline serving the route. Operating margin had a similar high correlation over 5-years, which the following results by industry: Along with revenue growth Mauboussin found that Earnings growth had similar poor correlations, and so it may shed light on why more focus should be applied to Gross and Operating Margins rather than Net Margins most of the time. IATA. As a result this is a decade where many low-cost carriers have grown more sophisticated in their product offerings and encroached into primary airports previously considered the domain of nework carriers. Despite the upward revision, profit margins also remain anaemic, with Mr Tyler noting that the revision only increased net profit margins from 0.5% to a still "miniscule" 0.6%. If you are an admin, please authenticate by logging in again. One caveat: While margins have tightened since 2015, they are still higher than they were from 2010 to 2013, when they were six percent or lower and oil prices were consistently above $80. Passenger numbers for the leading 100 carriers topped 3.8 billion in 2018 and, even while traffic growth slowed this year, are likely to end the decade at around the 4 billion mark. As per IATA, the airline industry losses reduced to -$9.7 billion in 2022, a significant improvement from the losses of $137.7 billion (-36.0% net margin) in 2020 and $42.1 billion (-8.3% net margin) in 2021. "Airlines haven't abandoned operational and customer-service metrics, but they are putting less emphasis on those factors." A Cost to High-Flying Profits After a wave of bankruptcies and. But as competition for these mail contracts became fierce, the airlines began competing destructively. Operating expenses include things like: Selling and marketing is also called SG&A, and so another easy way to identify the Gross Margin is to look for the profit number above SG&A-type expenses. But that roughly halved in 2017 and 2018 as the big Gulf carriers began moderating growth for a variety of internal and external reasons, and seat capacity on Middle East routes will be increased only fractionally in 2019 compared with the previous year. The model has been embraced by a number of operators. Gross Profit Margin = (Revenue - Cost of Goods Sold) / Revenue This number will be a percentage, where the higher the percentage the more profitable a company is on delivering their goods or services. More about profit margin . Industry Mergers: Airline industries have already, and will continue to merge operations in order to keep costs lower and try to aid in profit margin increases. ASK capacity growth peaking at 7% in 2018. US airlines ejoyed eight straight years of profitability. Full-service . This website uses cookies to improve your experience and for ads personalisation. In just one year, we have achieved an unprecedented financial turnaround. Access to this and all other statistics on 80,000 topics from, Show sources information Accessed March 05, 2023. https://www.statista.com/statistics/225856/ebit-margin-of-commercial-airlines-worldwide/, IATA. While airline capacity growth also began to slow, it failed to match the drop in GDP. Chart. Available: https://www.statista.com/statistics/232513/net-profit-of-commercial-airlines-worldwide/, Net profit of commercial airlines worldwide from 2006 to 2022, Market size of the global airline industry 2018-2021, Air traffic - worldwide revenue with passengers 2005-2022, Operating profit of airlines worldwide 2006-2022, Net profit of airlines worldwide 2006-2022, Passenger yield of airlines worldwide 2005-2022, Commercial airlines worldwide - fuel consumption 2005-2022, Worldwide air passenger traffic share by region 2019, Countries with the highest number of airline passengers globally 2020, Available seat kilometers of airlines worldwide - change by region 2011-2022, Monthly international revenue-passenger kilometers (RPK) change by region 2021, Available seat kilometers (ASK) in international air traffic by region 2021, Commercial airlines worldwide - passenger load factor 2005-2022, Monthly passenger load factor (PLF) on international flights by region 2020-2021, Leading airlines worldwide based on total number of passengers 2020, Passenger kilometers flown by airline worldwide 2020, Largest commercial airlines worldwide - ranked by sales 2021, Market value of selected airlines worldwide 2022, The leading airlines ranked by brand value 2022, Most punctual low cost carriers worldwide May 2021, Punctuality rate of airlines in North America May 2021, Punctuality of airlines in Europe May 2021, Air traffic - passenger volume forecast by region 2037, Air traffic - passenger growth rates forecast 2019-2040, Number of air passengers' growth forecast worldwide by region 2018-2050, Air passengers forecast worldwide by generation 2018-2050, International air passenger traffic by international carriers 2015-2021, Passenger traffic at worldwide airports by region December 2016, Distribution of airlines in Danish airspace 2018, Passengers transported by the leading foreign airlines in France 2017, Net profit per passenger transported by airlines worldwide 2005-2022, Forecast of worldwide airline fuel expenses 2005-2022, Worldwide airlines - non-fuel expenses 2005-2022, Air traffic growth - route & travel class 2014/2015, National and international commercial flights at Italy's leading airports 2020, Weekly seat capacity: North American domestic airlines by carrier 2016, U.S. airline ancillary: highest revenue as a share of total revenue Q3 2018, U.S. air carriers - total scheduled aircraft departures 1991-2020, Ancillary revenue generated by airlines: outside U.S. by source 2017, Leading European airlines ranked by seating capacity 2014, Air transport: turnover in France 2005-2018, Leading airlines for economy long-haul flights in Asia Pacific 2015, Total number of outbound flights from Luik-Bierset Airport in Belgium 2007-2020, Low Cost Carrier (LCC) market in the United States, Net profit of commercial airlines worldwide from 2006 to 2022 (in billion U.S. dollars), Find your information in our database containing over 20,000 reports. Delta had the industry's highest Seat Profit Margin (SPM) in 2017. Then you can access your favorite statistics via the star in the header. The average operating profit margin of the whole airline industry has been 2.8% in the last 10 years ( Figure 1) (IATA, 2014). Annual car sales worldwide 2010-2022, with a forecast for 2023, Number of cars sold in the U.S. 1951-2021, Battery electric vehicles in use worldwide 2016-2021, Annual gas prices in the United States 1990-2021, Automotive industry worldwide - statistics & facts, Motorcycle industry in the United States - statistics & facts, Profit from additional features with an Employee Account. Lets take another example, this one from the consulting business. The calculations and analysis are based on research on 10 prominent US airlines for the 2019 Oliver Wyman Airline Economic Analysis. To get a good sense of what makes a good gross margin, we will examine the average gross profit margin by industry over 20 years of data from the S&P 500. Average Operating (EBIT) Margin by Industry 20 Years of Data [S&P 500], What is a Good Net Profit Margin? This means that when they say, past performance is not a guarantee of future results, this is especially true for high revenue growth rates! Delta Air Lines, the most profitable airline group of the past decade, has alone amassed almost $30 billion in net profits over the first nine years of this decade - with another strong profit set to follow for 2019. As a Premium user you get access to background information and details about the release of this statistic. dive into gross profit margins and their prominent place in every companys income statement/ P&L. A lock ( LockA locked padlock ) or https:// means youve safely connected to the .gov website. Airline Industry recorded Net Loss compare to Net Profit achieved in previous quarter. By following these 5 steps. It is profit after Cost of Goods Sold or Cost of Sales. In, IATA. The best of the best: the portal for top lists & rankings: Strategy and business building for the data-driven economy: Show sources information But we can see a unique expense that the company calls Billable expenses. Share of total 4Q 2021 domestic operating revenue: Fares: $23.2 billion, 68.6%, compared to 61.4% in 4Q 2020. In 2018, 17 airline groups recorded operating profits in excess of $1 billion with the majority of these on track to do again in 2019. What does the future of aviation look like in 2022? While brands in the US market have been lost through the consolidation, in the rest of the world names and operations have largely remained intact even where acquisitions have taken place. Net profit of commercial airlines worldwide from 2006 to 2022 (in billion U.S. dollars) [Graph]. October 5, 2021. Airline Financial Data, United States Department of Transportation, Introduction to Transportation Statistics, Freight Logistics Optimization Works (FLOW), Government Transportation Financial Statistics, Local Area Transportation Characteristics (LATCH dataset), National Transportation Knowledge Network, Advisory Council on Transportation Statistics, Transportation Services Index 2023 Release Schedule, Fares: $86.7 billion, 66.7%, compared to 64.5% in 2020, Fuel: $23.0 billion 15.6%, compared to 9.8% in 2020, Labor: $52.6 billion 35.7%, compared to 39.7% in 2020. (October 5, 2021). Whether you're a frequent or occasional flier, there's a reason why airplane seats feel closer together and why fees seem to pile up at nearly $20 per head. Additionally, the impact of capacity growth on an already severely constrained infrastructure and overly congested airspace and airports must be addressed. The first Id like to look at is a more typical manufacturer of tangible goods; lets start with semiconductor producer Texas Instruments. By contrast airline seat capacity on routes within, to and from North America rose just under 30% to 1.5 billion. For a service-based business, Cost of Sales will include expenses like the labor required to serve the customer; a restaurant might have its wait staff and rent as part of Cost of Sales. The Atlanta-based megacarrier recorded a net income of $4.76 billion in 2019 with a revenue of $47 billion, a huge margin of 10%. Airlines with positive profit margins should maintain or improve their efficiency and leverage to maximize profitability ensuring that the positive profit margin is maintained or improved. In January 2016, prices per barrel slid to around $35 from a high of more than $110 in 2014. Register in seconds and access exclusive features. Figures prior to 2016 were taken from previous reports. Emirates & Philippine Airlines Reveal Interline Deal To Increase Passenger Connectivity, Over 9 Million Passengers Flew To Mexico In January, 18 Destinations: AirAsia X's Summer Operations From Kuala Lumpur, Qantas Says Too Many Airbus A380s Are Returning From Storage At Once, Vistara Brand To Discontinue After Merger With Air India, Why Republic Airways Is Suing Flight Students. These flag carriers were regarded as important strategic businesses with monopoly powers that conferred national pride and international prestige. To use individual functions (e.g., mark statistics as favourites, set Its not always the absolute gross margin which is most important when looking at this formula, but rather a comparison between peers. Airline industry profitability is expected to pick up modestly to USD7.5 billion in 2013, amid slightly faster growth, lower oil prices combined and an upwardly . Based in London, Graham has been with FlightGlobal for over 20 years predominantly working across its online news platforms and Airline Business. The past decade has been the most profitable in airline history, one in which consolidation has helped the strong grow stronger but seen a host of famous brands depart, and in which the spread of low-cost carriers left almost no market untouched. Tom is a partner, based in Washington DC, in Oliver Wyman's transportation and services practice, Business Jet Makers Downsize Despite Rebound In Private Air Travel, Large Business Jet Sales Cool Possibly Affecting Gulfstream, Dassault & Bombardier, How The U.S. Is Distributing Airline Bailout Funds In COVID-19 Relief Deal, Airlines Retire Aircraft But Its Not As Bad As You Think: Coronavirus Perspective, These Airlines Will Next Remove Seats To Carry Cargo And Medical Supplies On Passenger Aircraft Turned Into Freighters, How Air Canada Quickly Turned 777 Passenger Planes Into Quasi Freighters To Haul Medical Supplies, United Airlines Adds Beijing, Chengdu And Taipei Cargo-Only Flights, AirAsia Gives Refunds On A Case-By-Case Basis If Passengers Decline Credit Voucher During COVID-19 Travel Cancellations, 2019 Oliver Wyman Airline Economic Analysis, expected to grow 42.5 percent to more than 39,000 aircraft by 2029, the Carbon Offsetting and Reduction Scheme for International Aviation. Dollars). Overview and forecasts on trending topics, Industry and market insights and forecasts, Key figures and rankings about companies and products, Consumer and brand insights and preferences in various industries, Detailed information about political and social topics, All key figures about countries and regions, Market forecast and expert KPIs for 600+ segments in 150+ countries, Insights on consumer attitudes and behavior worldwide, Business information on 60m+ public and private companies, Detailed information for 35,000+ online stores and marketplaces. The term originated within the airline industry referring to airlines with a lower operating cost structure than their competitors. As airlines grapple with liquidity issues in the wake of COVID-19 with peak cash burn for US carriers of over $300M per day in early April, they've taken on nearly $40B in additional debt and provided the US Treasury with warrants for 1.7% of their equity. IATA figures show passenger load factors steadily rising across the decade, topping 82% in 2019. At the end of 2009 IndiGo carried just over 6 million passengers. 4Q 2021 international operating expenses: $7.8 billion, of which: Share of 4Q 2021 international operating expenses: Fuel: $1.8 billion, 22.7%, compared to 13.8% in 4Q 2020, Labor: $2.8 billion, 36.5%, compared to 44.5% in 4Q 2020. Unless, of course, something unexpected causes the skies to darken once again. In some cases, such as attempts to connect Europe to Asia, links have largely proved short-lived.
How To Find Past Purchases On Offerup, The Nortons London Gangsters, St Louis Blues Russian Players, Italian Lemon Trees For Sale, Articles A